New vs. Used Pinball Machines: Which Is Right for You?
(Meta Description: Deciding between a new or used pinball machine? Our guide breaks down the pros and cons of each, helping you make the perfect choice for your home and budget.)
So, you’ve decided to take the exciting leap into pinball ownership. Congratulations! One of the first and biggest decisions you'll face is whether to buy a brand-new machine straight from the manufacturer or a pre-loved classic from the secondary market.
Both paths lead to the same destination—fun!—but they offer different journeys. At Premium Pinballs, we want to ensure you make the choice that’s right for your budget, your desires, and your lifestyle. Let’s explore the benefits of each.
The Allure of a New Pinball Machine
Buying new is like getting a shiny new car straight off the lot. It’s a thrilling experience with some fantastic perks.
Pros:
Latest Technology & Features: Enjoy cutting-edge displays, intricate mechs, and deep, evolving rule sets. New games often receive software updates that add new features for years.
Warranty & Reliability: A full manufacturer’s warranty protects your investment, giving you peace of mind against early-life component failures.
Zero Wear and Tear: You are the first owner! The playfield is pristine, the cabinet art is flawless, and every component is fresh.
The "Hot New Thing": There’s a unique joy in being part of the initial buzz surrounding a latest-release game and discovering its secrets alongside the community.
Cons:
Higher Initial Cost: New machines, especially Premium and LE models, represent a significant financial investment.
Depreciation: Like a new car, a new pinball machine loses value the moment it leaves the showroom (though popular titles can hold value well).
Ideal For: Collectors who want the latest tech, players who desire warranty protection, and those who want a flawless, "out-of-the-box" experience.
The Charm of a Used Pinball Machine
The used market is a treasure trove of pinball history, from beloved 90s classics to modern titles that are no longer in production.
Pros:
Proven Classics & Lower Cost: You can own legendary titles like The Addams Family or Medieval Madness for less than a new Premium machine. The market is also full of fantastic, more affordable modern games.
Depreciation Has Stabilized: A well-maintained classic has already gone through its major depreciation and can often hold its value or even appreciate.
Instant Access to Legends: Many of the "Greatest of All Time" pins are only available on the used market.
Community Vetted: You can research a used game extensively. The community knows its common issues, strengths, and hidden secrets.
Cons:
"As-Is" Condition: You inherit the machine’s history. Wear and tear on the playfield, faded cabinet art, and older electronics are realities you must assess.
Potential for Repairs: Older machines will likely need more maintenance. You should be comfortable with basic repairs or have a trusted technician on speed dial.
No Warranty: What you see is generally what you get, without the safety net of a manufacturer's warranty.
Ideal For: Budget-conscious buyers, collectors seeking specific classics, hobbyists who enjoy tinkering and restoration, and those who want a proven, community-loved game.
Making Your Choice: Key Questions to Ask
Still unsure? Ask yourself these questions:
What is my budget? Be realistic about the purchase price and any potential immediate or long-term maintenance costs.
Am I handy with a multimeter? If the idea of swapping a solenoid or adjusting a switch fills you with dread, a new machine with a warranty might be your best bet.
Is there a specific title I MUST have? If your heart is set on a Twilight Zone or Attack from Mars, the used market is your only option.
Do I love the latest tech or classic charm? Do you crave LCD screens and complex mechs, or do you love the glow of incandescent bulbs and the simplicity of a DMD?
FAQ Section
Q: Is a used pinball machine a risky purchase?
A: It can be, which is why buying from a reputable dealer is crucial. We at Premium Pinballs fully shop and refurbish our used machines, so you get a reliable, play-tested game. Avoid risky "as-is, untested" online auctions if you're a beginner.
Q: Can I still find parts for an older used machine?
A: Yes! The pinball community is incredible, and a robust aftermarket industry exists. Parts for most popular games from the 90s onward are readily available from online retailers.
Q: What's a good "first" pinball machine?
A: For a new first machine, titles like Stern's Godzilla Pro or Foo Fighters Pro are fantastic. For a used first pin, consider a well-loved Theatre of Magic, World Cup Soccer, or a later Stern like Iron Man.
No matter which path you choose, the goal is the same: years of enjoyment. At Premium Pinballs, we offer both pristine new games and meticulously refurbished classics. Let us help you find the perfect pinball machine for your home.